|
NOTE: Thank you to
Lynn Michaels for pointing out that Omega 3 may not
lower serotonin. Originally I had published this critique
stating that Omega 3 depletes tryptophan, but when I re-read
Kathleen Kendall-Tackett's original email, it was clear I had
misunderstood her. What she did say is that Omega 3 "moderates"
the effect of pro-inflammatory cytokines which deplete
serotonin. At least that is what is being claimed. The
jury is out on whether that is a good thing.
I did find one
article which stated that Omega 3s actually induced manic
"switching" which is a scary proposition. See page 975 of
http://www.granitescientific.com/granitescientific%20home%20page_files/omega%203%20mood%20disorders.pdf
which states that most people agree that an effective
antidepressant should induce manic switching and there is some
evidence that Omega 3s do this.
The comparison between Omega 3 and antidepressants is disturbing
and definitely warrants further research. However, according to
Lynn Michaels, there is no reason for concern about using Omega
3.
Breastfeeding and
Medications: Resources for Moms
Click on these
hotlinks to read the highlights of this article:
basic
conclusion and point of this analysis
◦◦◦
babies
are not disposable
◦◦◦
central
nervous system drug levels elevated compared to serum levels in
babies
◦◦◦
permanent
brain changes, lifelong anxiety & depression
◦◦◦
drugs lack
efficacy and have negative effects on mothers, including suicide
and homicide
◦◦◦
"experts"
leading families to the slaughter
◦◦◦
◦◦◦
hale on
medicating and breastfeeding
◦◦◦
mothers'
response to meds
◦◦◦
the liability
distraction technique
◦◦◦
doctors are
concerned about potential effects of drugs on babies
◦◦◦
infant
sensitivity to drugs
◦◦◦
observation
does not prevent problems
◦◦◦
concerns over
tricyclics
◦◦◦
serious
concerns about prozac, including coma!!!
◦◦◦
"at least 30
babies" studied to prove that Zoloft is "so safe"
◦◦◦
assumptions
that herbals are unsafe
◦◦◦
illogical
comparison of vaccines to mother's milk
◦◦◦
yummy! tainted
mommy/PhRMA milk!
◦◦◦
loss
of milk production
◦◦◦
the "educate
your doctor on how safe Zoloft is for your baby" campaign
Before you read
this, I want you to know that I am an enthusiastic breastfeeding
supporter. I have nursed my oldest for over 3 years, and
overcome hardships and even breastfed him while on Zoloft as a
new mom (read the whole story
here). My second child is still nursing and he just recently
turned one. He is my little drug-free baby! Unfortunately, I had
to learn the hard way that Zoloft is a very dangerous substance.
If it is so great for depression, how is it possible that it put
me in the psych ward after only three days, made me suicidal,
homicidal, and caused hallucinations?
I wasn't even depressed
when I began taking it (I was given samples because of high
anxiety over a life-threatening choking incident that occurred
with my baby when he was only 3 days old), but I did become
psychotic on it almost immediately. I have been on the other end
of the breastfeeding advice, and the new mom advice, and the
advice that if you are worrying about your baby you must have a
psychiatric disorder. I know how confusing it is in the
beginning and I also know what it feels like to recover from a
birth. It isn't always easy, even when you have the best
situation like I did following the home birth of my second, a 10
pound boy!
I had many people
tell me that Zoloft is fine for nursing, and many who questioned
that. My son's pediatrician told me that the data in the studies only
goes up to 100 mg of Zoloft, and that most of them were at 50 mg
when studied, and that "the only side effect noted was excessive
sleepiness." I'm not sure how accurate any of the
information you can find on this is, but regardless of the
different dosages in studies - here is a reality check - excessive sleepiness
is not a good thing in a baby! It increases the likelihood of
SIDS. Furthermore, you can't eliminate side effects by giving
the drug to a baby. Just because you can't ask the baby
what it feels like doesn't mean that the baby feels ok. With the
exception of side effects that might not be possible in a baby,
such as those that require verbalization or prior knowledge to
imagine (or hallucinate) a certain type of situation, any side
effect listed in the drug's label should be considered as
possible or applicable to a baby who is exposed to a drug.
We may not be able to get inside a
baby's head, but babies most certainly can and do suffer and
feel real feelings, and we should not treat them like they are
immune to drug effects simply because they can't tell us about
them. Baby humans are way more helpless than most other animal
babies, and they should be protected and treated especially
well. They should not be treated like they're disposable.
Read this before you read the information
from Hale, including that "if the infant dose is one tenth of
the maternal dose, it is generally well tolerated":
Infant Physiology
(click here to read the
whole article)
Infants' abilities to absorb, metabolize, and
eliminate drugs determine how these drugs will
affect them. Compared with adults, infants have
a higher gastric pH, causing basic compounds,
which remain un-ionized, to have higher
absorption rates than do acidic compounds.
Infants also have lower levels of albumin,
resulting in higher amounts of free/unbound (and
therefore active) medication.8 Liver
metabolic enzymes are immature in infants,
decreasing the rate of degradation of
medication. In addition, neonates' kidneys have
a glomerular filtration rate that is 30% to 40%
of that in adults.7 Finally, the
blood-brain barrier in newborns is not fully
developed, and central nervous
system concentrations of some lipid-soluble
compounds may reach levels that are 10 to 30
times those in serum.9 As
a result of all of these factors, medications
that reach the serum in neonates, as compared
with those that reach the serum of adults or
children older than 6 months, are more likely to
be active, less likely to be metabolized and
excreted, and more likely to cross into the
brain.Milk-to-Plasma Ratio
Medication concentration in milk is frequently
compared with the concentration in maternal
serum to quantify the extent of passage; this is
known as the milk-to-plasma ratio (M/P). In
general, compounds that are weakly
protein-bound, highly lipid-soluble, weakly
basic, and small in molecular size have higher
M/P ratios.10 Ratios greater than 1
indicate that the medication is present in
higher concentrations in breast milk than in
maternal serum. The higher the M/P ratio, the
greater the infant exposure to medication. |
|
Since stopping Zoloft I have read studies showing that
infant
mice fed SSRIs had permanent brain changes
and life-long anxiety
and depression. Sadly I have to worry almost every day about
what this drug could have done to my son. Even though he was
only exposed to Zoloft at high levels for a few months, I was on
150 mg for part of that time, and it is highly unlikely that he came out of the
experience unaffected. A newborn should never be put at risk the
way my baby was (from both exposure to the drugs, and from the
effect the drug had on me, his mother!). I hope that if you are a new mom reading this,
considering taking an SSRI, and you have questions, you will
write to me at
amy@uniteforlife.org
before you make your decision. I have many other sources of
information other than this article that you can use to make a
more informed decision on SSRI use than you might get from your
average lactation consultant.
◦◦◦top◦◦◦
Thomas Hale's
research on breastfeeding and drugs leaves much to be desired!
For those of you who haven't heard of Thomas Hale, he is pretty
much the only "expert" ever cited by breastfeeding advocates and
pro-breastfeeding health professionals. He promotes the use of
Zoloft in nursing moms, based on "dozens" of studies (more on
that later) and blood tests on a whopping 30 infants (which may
have only
measured plasma levels of Zoloft in infants up to the dose 100
mg in the mother).
Some breastfeeding supporters also frequently cite Kathleen
Kendall-Tackett, IBCLC. Kendall-Tackett is a well-respected
author of articles and books about depression in new mothers,
and although she stakes her reputation on being pro-natural
alternatives, upon examination it seems as if she is somewhat
unaware of many of the dangers of drugs. Because although she is
"no fan of antidepressants," she has
allies and colleagues who
are.
She encourages new mothers to breastfeed despite episodes
of psychosis, which has been interpreted by many breastfeeding
advocates to mean - breastfeed while taking antipsychotic
drugs!!! See
these posts
from a while back on the CHAADA message board to read about
how she compares Omega 3 to SSRIs and claims that they work the
same way, and that antidepressants are anti-inflammatory, and
how she doubts that SSRIs could raise cortisol. She also
claims that Paxil rebuilds hippocampal tissue in PTSD patients,
but it is doubtful that this is anything other than tumor
growth. In addition, the studies cited as evidence are funded by
pharmaceutical companies and they involve getting people on
drugs and providing additional supplies of drugs for subjects
following the completion of the studies. There are obvious
shortcomings of the theoretical basis that the most
commonly-cited experts are using as they lead new moms to the
slaughter.
Look at how
blatantly pro-antidepressant Dr. Hale is, and how badly he
fails to understand that
SSRIs do not even work.
If he were
concerned about the effects of maternal depression on babies
then he needs to take notice that the drugs don't even work, and
they cause worse depression,
suicide, and
homicide! It's likely that if a baby's
levels of the drug get too high, he or she could die from "SIDS"
or
serotonin syndrome. I
have posted an old article by Thomas Hale here, and inserted my
own commentary in bold maroon. I also added emphasis in bold or
italics to many of his rather ironic statements.
◦◦◦top◦◦◦
◦◦◦◦
|
Depression and
Breastfeeding by Thomas Hale, M.D.
Almost every day I get a phone call from a woman who
is terribly depressed, who needs medication,
(No, she needs something else!
Such as rest after childbirth, subsequent
exercise, sunlight & fresh air, fish oil,
Vitamin C, B vitamins, homeopathy, chiropractic, good
nutrition, some fun, some friends, a feeling of
satisfaction and success as a mother, and some support.) but who has
been told by various healthcare professionals that she
should not breastfeed her infant because it may not be
safe. Every one of these mothers tells me the same
thing: "Breastfeeding is the only joy I have in my life
right now, and I don't want to quit."
(Get ready for: "Don't listen to
that doctor. Only listen to me.")
All drugs transfer into milk, but most do so in such
small quantities that they are insignificant to the
infant. This is particularly true of most
antidepressants. Dozens of studies have shown that
mothers can use certain antidepressants safely and with
minimal, if any, side effects in their infants.
(What is safe? How can he say that
dozens of studies show antidepressants are safe? The
drugs were usually studied at most for up to 6-12 weeks
for FDA approval and from that data alone there were
twice the suicides. Based on additional postmarketing
data, the FDA approved a BLACK BOX warning on SSRIs for
increased suicide and other effects, so how can one say
that they are safe? Perhaps since this article is a
little old, from 2002, its out-of-date qualities will be
revised by Hale - given the new information available to
him.) We
also know from numerous studies that infants of
depressed mothers do not develop as well as they should,
with delays in speech patterns and other behavioral
skills. Due to these documented effects from failure
to treat (Really? Documented
effects from "failure" to "treat?" Or documented effects
of depression, or even medicated depression? Delays in
speech patterns - that sounds a bit similar to slurred
speech caused by Prozac!) the mother, most of us in this field now
strongly recommend that severely depressed mothers be
treated with antidepressants. The choice depends on the
patient's needs, the age of the infant, and certain
other conditions. (The worst
thing you can do for someone who is severely depressed
is give them an SSRI. That will only push them over the
edge, as we have seen in so many cases of mothers
killing their own children.)
It is, therefore, important that mothers seek the
advice of experts (like him?)
before abandoning breastfeeding.
Depression often responds quickly to medications,
(That's a bit of an overstatement.
Medications are no better than active placebo, and in
the majority of the studies, which were hidden from the
FDA and the public, they did worse. How is 40% of people
improving and 60% not improving - even though 40% also
improved on an active placebo - considered so effective?
Logic says that instead, Hale should be saying that
"Most of the time depression does not improve with
medication." Besides, depression
does not respond. People
respond. Let's not forget the mother and the baby we are
talking about here. People often don't "respond" in any
other way than this: the mother goes psychotic on the
new drug, becomes a danger to herself or the baby, or at
best, she become more depressed. And his statements also
neglect the basic question of the article, which is "Is
it safe for my baby?" which as we will see below, it
obviously is not. See particularly his
notes
about Prozac.) and
mother and infant can continue to enjoy a
wonderful
breastfeeding experience, without the depression.
(He sounds so much like a
commercial here. It is hard not to roll my eyes while
reading this. See
below for details on the
"wonderful experience" you will have while breastfeeding
if you happen to be on Prozac and your
baby goes into a coma.) |
◦◦◦top◦◦◦
But Is
It Safe for My Baby? Medications and Breastfeeding
by Thomas W. Hale
Issue 111 March/April 2002
http://www.mothering.com/articles/new_baby/breastfeeding/medications-breastfeeding.html
Sidebar:
Depression and Breastfeeding
The decision to prescribe medication for a
breastfeeding mother is one of the most contentious
areas in the clinical practice of medicine. For legal
reasons alone (Oh really? There
can't be any other reason to be concerned about the
effects of drugging on a baby, now can there?),
most manufacturers and many physicians advise patients
to discontinue breastfeeding while they take various
medications. (When instead they
might do better to help the mother find completely safe
natural solutions to their illnesses and protect the
mother and the baby and the breastfeeding relationship.) Look at any package insert; invariably, the
manufacturer recommends that the physician avoid
prescribing the drug for breastfeeding mothers. Often
doctors advise nursing mothers to "pump and dump" while
taking an antibiotic, not knowing that they may be
initiating a dangerous spiral toward a poor milk supply,
or endangering the infant by introducing a poorer food
source such as formula early on.
The fact is that all medications enter breastmilk,
but most are so low in concentration that they have no
clinical effect on infants. There are thousands of
research papers illustrating this point.1-3 With few
exceptions, most drugs can be safely used by
breastfeeding mothers. So the decision about whether
to take the drug and breastfeed, or to risk the hazards
of introducing artificial formulas to your infant, is
really up to each mother. (Gee,
what sounds better to you, giving your baby Zoloft or
milk from a cow? You're going to have to do an awful lot
of convincing either to prove that Zoloft is super-safe,
or that formula is riskier. Given that the average new
mom doubts that formula would be very unsafe compared to
drugs, let's go with making Zoloft appear safer or
completely safe! That ought to do the trick. )
Most authoritative sources suggest that if the daily
dose to the infant is less than 10 percent of the
mother's dose, it is unlikely to bother the infant.4
This is generally
accurate, and very few drugs exceed this limit. The
American Academy of Pediatrics has published an
extensive list of drugs acceptable for use by
breastfeeding mothers.5 Most physicians are not aware of
this, unfortunately, and it may be a nursing mother's
job to bring this information to them.
(And it is my job to point out
that the American Academy of Pediatrics lists antidepressants as a class a
potential concern for breastfeeding moms.
"Antidepressants:
All antidepressants listed by the AAP Committee on Drugs
are considered to have an unknown effect on nursing
infants and may be of concern.
http://www.femalepatient.com/html/arc/sig/pharma/articles/article_3.asp)
Transmission of Drugs into Breastmilk
Drugs transfer into milk largely as a function of their
plasma levels. As the mother's plasma level rises, the
concentration in her milk rises, too. Most drugs are
absorbed into the bloodstream, rise to a peak, and then
rapidly decline to a much lower level. Therefore, to
reduce your infant's exposure avoid breastfeeding when
your medication peaks in your plasma. An ideal way to do
this is to nurse your infant before you take the
medication. The next time you feed (perhaps several
hours later) the drug concentration in your blood may be
much lower, and therefore the concentration in milk will
be lower. This works well for drugs that must be taken
repeatedly during the day (see fig. 1) but not so well
for drugs that have long durations (half-lives), or for
mothers who breastfeed every hour or two. Remember,
drugs don't stay in milk; they enter as the mom's plasma
level is increasing, then exit as the mother's levels
start to drop.
Of course, if the drug is not absorbed by the mother
or the infant it presents no problem.
Large-molecular-weight drugs, such as heparin,
interferon, and insulin, barely penetrate into milk and
are poorly absorbed by infants. If a drug is not
absorbed orally, it is unlikely that the infant will be
affected (see Table 2).
Evaluating Infant Sensitivity to Medications
Of course, some infants are more sensitive than
others to medications. Newborn and premature
infants, those with poor liver or kidney functions, and
those with specific pathologies, such as severe
breathing difficulties, may be more sensitive.
(Babies born to mothers who used
SSRIs in pregnancy are actually more likely to be born
with defects like lung problems, heart problems, or
perhaps other problems listed here because of SSRI-induced
preterm birth, and tragically, many infants will never
survive a pregnancy if their mother is using SSRIs.
Studies show twice the rate of miscarriage, and more
preterm brths, stillbirths, and neonatal death with
pregnancy exposure.) Infants
subject to breathing difficulties should not be exposed
to Valium-like drugs, beta-blocker high blood pressure
medications, and sedating antihistamines without close
monitoring. Neonates in the first month of life should
not be exposed to sulfonamides or other drugs with high
protein binding that might increase bilirubin levels.
Ill or weakened infants should always be closely
evaluated before a breastfeeding mother takes
medication. But a big, healthy six month old can
probably metabolize drugs as well as you can and is much
less sensitive to the small amount of drugs present in
your milk.
Ideal Drug Factors
A nursing mother should choose drugs that have shorter
half-lives. If possible, as noted above, she should not
breastfeed when the drug peaks in her circulation.
Although not contraindicated, she should be more
cautious of medications with long half-lives. Certain
drugs (Prozac and Demerol, for instance), when
metabolized by the liver, produce active metabolites
with incredibly long half-lives, which can build up over
time in the infant and produce side effects. But even
many medications with longer half-lives (phenobarbital,
etc.) can be used safely, if the baby is observed
closely. (As though observing a
baby will prevent any ill effects from occurring - by the
time you notice something is wrong, much damage has been
done. It might even be too late - see below on comas
caused by Prozac -The same argument is often used about
how doctors need to observe and monitor patients on
SSRIs. But that hasn't proven to show much benefit to
patients at all.)
◦◦◦top◦◦◦
Drugs That Directly Affect Milk Production
Quite apart from their ability to enter milk, some drugs
have the potential to affect the production of
breastmilk, either increasing or suppressing it. Early
lactation is apparently highly sensitive to the level of
circulating prolactin, the milk-producing hormone from
the mother's pituitary. Drugs that stimulate prolactin
early on, such as metoclopramide (Reglan),
domperidone, and other dopamine antagonists,
(these dopamine affecting drugs
are actually encouraged for breastfeeding mothers on a
short term basis to stimulate milk production)
may actually increase the rate of breastmilk
production. Some drugs, such as birth control pills with
estrogens, are well known for suppressing lactation if
administered early postpartum. Stay away from
estrogen-containing birth control pills until at least
six weeks postpartum, and then watch your milk supply
closely. If it is suppressed, stop the birth control
pills.
Specific Drugs
Analgesics
The analgesics most commonly used by breastfeeding women
are acetaminophen and ibuprofen. Both are ideal, because
the levels they attain in breastmilk are largely
subclinical, and both are cleared for pediatric use.
(Whereas SSRIs are not
approved for use in infants, but he recommends
medication anyway.) Levels of
ibuprofen transferred into milk following 400 mg
maternal doses are generally less than 1 mg per liter of
milk. Long-acting nonsteroidals (NSAIDS) such as
naproxen (Aleve, Naprosyn) should be avoided, although
they are not absolutely contraindicated if used only
briefly, say for a few days.
Codeine and hydrocodone are often used for mild
postpartum pain. The amount of codeine transferred into
milk is marginal, although sedation and apnea have been
reported with frequent, higher doses. If doses of
codeine and hydrocodone are kept low and administered
after breastfeeding, few cases of neonatal sedation have
been reported. In many respects, morphine continues to
be an ideal strong opiate for breastfeeding mothers in
moderate to severe pain. Due to poor oral absorption (26
percent), morphine produces only minimal sedation in
breastfed infants. Frequent and repeated exposure,
however, can lead to accumulation in the infant and
should be avoided.
Antihistamines/Decongestants
Breastfeeding women often use antihistamines, sometimes
in combination with decongestants, for cold symptoms or
seasonal allergies. The older families of
antihistamines—diphenhydramine (Benadryl),
chlorpheniramine(Chlor-Trimeton), and
brompheniramine(Dimetapp)—may produce sedation in
infants but not always. Because sedation in newborns may
predispose them to breathing difficulties, nonsedating
antihistamines, such as cetirizine (Zyrtec) and
loratadine (Claritin), are preferred.
As for the decongestants present in many cold
remedies, be cautious. (Yes, be
cautious. He doesn't mention that you should not use
many cold medicines while taking an antidepressant. If
the drug you're taking is just another serotonin
reuptake inhibitor in disguise, or some other serotonin
increaser, then you risk
serotonin syndrome. Look for the ingredient
dextromethorphan in cold meds.) New data from my laboratories
suggest that pseudoephedrine may significantly suppress
milk production, and I no longer recommend it for
breastfeeding mothers. Many antihistamine/decongestant
preparations are not very effective for colds and flu
symptoms anyway and may not prove beneficial enough to
risk side effects in the infant. To treat seasonal
allergies (allergic rhinitis), intranasal steroids are
ideal for breastfeeding mothers, as their systemic
absorption is minimal.
Antibiotics
Virtually all antibiotics are safe for breastfeeding
mothers to use, with the possible exception of the "Cipro"
family and the sulfonamides early postpartum.
Penicillins, erythromycins, and cephalosporins enter
milk only in trace levels and rarely produce allergies
or changes in GI flora in the infant. Rashes, thrush,
and diarrhea are the only likely consequences of
exposure to these families of drugs, and they are rare.
Although there are exceptions to this rule, most
fluoroquinolone antibiotics (Cipro) should be avoided,
but some of them (Ofloxacin) are not definitely
contraindicated.
Sulfonamide drugs are seldom used during the last
trimester of pregnancy and the first month postpartum,
due to the potential for increasing free bilirubin
levels in the infant. After the first month of life,
sulfonamides are quite safe in most infants who do not
have elevated bilirubin levels.
Metronidazole (Flagyl), which is commonly used for
trichomoniasis, giardiasis, and anaerobic infections, is
controversial due to rat studies that suggested it was
mutagenic. Today Metronidazole is not considered
mutagenic in humans, and it is commonly used in
pediatrics, particularly with premature infants. The
tetracyclines can be briefly used by breastfeeding
women. While many of the older tetracyclines were poorly
absorbed, especially in milk, this is not necessarily
true for newer ones like doxycycline or minocycline.
However, doxycycline is still preferred in pediatric
patients because the risk of dental staining is lower
than with other tetracycline products. If the treatments
are kept brief (no more than several weeks), the amount
transferred and the effect on skeletal growth and dental
discoloration will be minimal.6
Antihypertensives
Antihypertensives include the beta receptors, calcium
channel blockers, angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE)
inhibitors, and several others. Many of these agents
have been thoroughly studied in breastfeeding
mothers.7-10 Certain beta blockers, such as acebutolol
and atenolol, have been associated with a higher
incidence of hypotension and hypoglycemia in breastfed
infants and should be avoided.11,12 Propranolol and
metoprolol are probably preferred, due to their lower
levels in milk. But all infants exposed to the beta
blocker family should be closely monitored for apnea,
weakness, and low blood sugar. Several of the
calcium channel blockers, including verapamil, bepridil,
nifedipine, and nimodipine, produce exceedingly low
levels in milk and are therefore preferred.
ACE inhibitors are more problematic. Due to extreme
potency in neonates, they are universally
contraindicated in the last trimester of pregnancy.
Although the reported levels in milk are low, the use of
these agents in the early neonatal period is probably
too risky. Captopril or enalapril can probably be used
by breastfeeding mothers several weeks to one month
postpartum, with due caution.13,14
◦◦◦top◦◦◦
Antidepressants
With the introduction of newer antidepressants, the
number of patients receiving treatment for depression
has risen significantly. Societal perception of
antidepressant therapy has likewise changed to a point
where it is quite acceptable to seek and receive
treatment for depression. About 15 to 20 percent
of postpartum women experience clinical depression,
although about 80 percent will experience postpartum
blues. Recent evidence that depression may interfere
with optimal parenting, and that infants of depressed
women may suffer from developmental problems, has
increased the urgency of treating this syndrome in
breastfeeding women.15, 16 (And by
treating, he means - drugging! With drugs that are
ineffective...)
The tricyclic family, which includes amitriptyline (Elavil)
and numerous others, is the oldest family of
antidepressants. According to more than 40 published
articles about various members of this family, the
amount transferred into human milk is for the most part
quite low. However, tricyclics are replete with
untoward side effects in the mother, including
constipation, sedation, dry mouth, and blurred vision.
They are also horribly toxic in overdose, and most
clinicians are reluctant to prescribe them for patients
who are already depressed and at risk for suicide.
Thus far, however, neurobehavioral development of
breastfed infants exposed to tricyclic antidepressants
in breastmilk appears normal.17
The most popular family of antidepressants is the
serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), including
fluoxetine (Prozac), sertraline (Zoloft), paroxetine (Paxil),
and others. Prozac, the best-selling of this group,
is presently the subject of some concern. It is
metabolized to an active, long half-life metabolite
called norfluoxetine, which has a long 360-hour
half-life. This metabolite has been found in high
levels in the plasma of several breastfed infants and
has been correlated with a number of untoward effects
such as colic, lengthy crying
(the last thing a mom
with PPD or Prozac-induced depression needs is a baby who
won't stop crying), vomiting
(to make the baby
even better fed, more full and satisfied, and healthier
than he would have been on straight breast milk from a
depressed, un-medicated mother who didn't have to spend
her whole life breastfeeding because her baby keeps
throwing up and is never satisfied or full),
decreased sleep
(and we know that a
depressed mother needs to stay up trying to get a baby
to go to sleep, and that a baby who can't sleep will
turn out so much healthier than the well-rested,
non-resented baby of a
non-medicated mom), watery stools,
(more diapers to change, more
clothes splattered and stained that need to be washed by
the depressed mother) and coma.
Because Prozac now has
FDA clearance for use in pregnancy, infants of
mothers taking it will be born with high levels of the
drug in their plasma
(And would infants whose mothers
took it before it had FDA clearance have low levels of
the drug? - OK now that's just me being sarcastic. But
clearly Hale needs to do some better editing. LOL.) In these cases,
it is possible that the small amount transferred in
breastmilk will continue to build to toxic levels.
("FDA cleared" toxic levels!)
Fluoxetine should no longer be viewed as a preferred
product for breastfeeding mothers with newborns, whose
infants may not be able to eliminate the drug well. In
older infants it is probably much safer.
(Yes, because
coma in an older infant is much safer than coma in a
younger one.)
The use of Zoloft, on the other hand, has been
reported in more than 30 breastfed
infants, and appears to transfer poorly to the infant
and with no reported effects.18,19
Thus far plasma levels in most infants have been
close to or below the limit of detection,
(How can something be below a
limit of detection? If you can't detect it, then it
isn't present at all, so just say it was not detected.)
with no reports of untoward effects in the infant.
At this time, Zoloft is probably the SSRI of
choice for nursing mothers (I
should say so. Based on your totally convincing
evidence. After all you did say you studied at least 30
babies. And with no effects on the babies. But you did
detect the Zoloft in the blood of some of those 30
babies. And based on those 30, it's likely that Zoloft
IS also detectable in other babies that you haven't
studied. So a drug that "has no effects" - according to
your extensive research- is
probably the
best one. Unless, of course, you are trying to get babies
to act weird so that a doctor can diagnose THEM with
some sort of disorder and write a prescription for
meds for infant or childhood depression.) Several reports of Paxil
use suggest that its levels in breastmilk are
exceedingly low, and the amount transferred to the
infant would be minimal. (Yay,
minimal amounts of poison being given to my baby! Let's
just put up a bumper sticker on the cafepress store that
says - "Hale MD loves (with a heart) tainted PhRMA
milk." I wonder, would HE drink a bottle of this stuff
pumped from one of his patients on Zoloft, Paxil, or
Prozac? What about 8 bottles of it per day?)
◦◦◦top◦◦◦
Contraceptives
As noted above, estrogen-containing oral contraceptives
may dramatically suppress lactation and therefore infant
growth. The estrogen component, if used early
postpartum, is well known to significantly suppress
lactation in some women, leading to early
supplementation and ultimately suppression of
breastfeeding. The progestins in general do not suppress
lactation in most women; medroxyprogesterone
(Depo-Provera) has been used by many women with success,
although there have been some reports of milk
suppression. Because of this risk, oral progestin-only
mini pills are the preferred oral contraceptives for
breastfeeding mothers.
Corticosteroids
Steroid use is categorized according to the method of
administration: oral, inhaled, intranasal, or topical.
The transfer of oral prednisone and prednisolone into
human milk is generally quite low and is dependent on
the maternal dose. With extremely high doses of 120
mg/day, breastmilk levels vary from 54 to 627
micrograms/liter of milk and only provide approximately
47 micrograms/day to the infant, an insignificant
amount. The transfer of methylprednisolone into milk is
equally minimal. In general, the systemic absorption of
topical, inhaled, and intranasal steroids is so low that
these agents are unlikely to pose problems for a
breastfed infant. Although the topical application of
low-potency steroids directly to the nipple can be
overdone, minimal and infrequent applications cause no
problems. But note that only low-potency steroid
creams/ointments, such as hydrocortisone or
triamcinolone, should be used on the nipple.
Finally, steroids have potent and long-lasting
aftereffects in infants when misused, and the long-term
exposure of breastfed infants to maternal steroids
should be approached with a risk-versus -benefit
assessment that includes length and duration of
exposure, route of administration, and the overall
maternal dose. The infant should be followed closely for
appropriate growth and development parameters.
Herbal Medications
Herbal drugs are frequently viewed as safer alternatives
to conventional medications, but this is not necessarily
the case, particularly for pregnant and breastfeeding
mothers. Most studies of herbal products are poorly
done, and their reported efficacy is often exaggerated.
(But studies done on
pharmaceuticals are always top-notch, and the efficacy
of drugs made by PhRMA is never exaggerated?)
Herbals that contain anticholinergics, or more
importantly the pyrrolizidine alkaloids, can be
extremely dangerous and should be avoided. These include
chapparal, jin bu huan, gerymander, comfrey tea,
mistletoe, skullcap, margosa oil, mate tea, pennyroyal
oil, blue cohosh, and many others.
Other herbals, however, have excellent safety
profiles. There is little evidence of acute toxicity
from fenugreek, for instance, commonly believed to
stimulate milk production (although data documenting its
milk-stimulating effect are sketchy at best). A
significant body of literature exists suggesting that
St. John's wort is relatively efficacious as an
antidepressant and devoid of significant side effects.
We do not know, however, if it transfers into human
milk, or if it is safe in breastfeeding mothers. At
this time, using herbal products while breastfeeding is
risky at best, primarily due to our limited experience
and knowledge, and should in general be avoided
altogether. (St. Johns Wort has
been claimed to increase serotonin just like SSRIs, so
unless you see evidence otherwise I would say,
definitely avoid it. However, notice how he says that
herbals should be avoided altogether. Why hasn't he
studied these products instead of spending his career
only studying pharmaceutical, synthetic drugs? Could it
be that he has an incentive somehow to promote medical
solutions? Could someone be sponsoring the "safety"
studies for breastfeeding moms in order to get more
babies exposed to them and make them sicker?)
Vaccines
There are occasions when breastfeeding mothers may
require vaccination, as in the case of women who are
rubella negative, those who need influenza
vaccines, (no thanks!)
or those planning to visit foreign countries
(because foreign countries are
full of sick people whereas here in America we're all so
healthy and non-contagious). While it is
possible that even weakened (attenuated) viruses, such
as those used in vaccines, can transfer to the infant,
thus far no serious untoward effects have been reported.
The Centers for Disease Control and the American Academy
of Pediatrics clearly state that all vaccines can be
safely used in breastfeeding mothers.
(Perhaps the AAP needs to watch
its language. Perhaps they should state that all
vaccines (in their opinion) are considered safe to a
breastfeeding infant exposed to components of a vaccine
in mother's milk. However considering all the
ingredients in vaccines - remember, there are other
ingredients besides attenuated viruses - I want to know
why Hale hasn't studied their effect on babies. Perhaps
that would not be noticeable compared to the high
exposure the babies already get from shots at "well"
visits.)
Alcohol
We know that small amounts of alcohol do transfer into
human milk. The amount an infant receives following
several drinks is not enough to harm most normal
infants. Mothers should, however, limit their intake to
no more than two small drinks. Some infants may not like
the taste imparted to milk and may refuse breastfeeding,
but this passes quickly. Women who drink excessively
should wait until they are sober to begin breastfeeding.
Chronic or binge drinking should, of course, be
discouraged, as higher levels of alcohol are believed to
significantly suppress milk production.
(But what about the
antidepressants? He can encourage use of drugs similar
in action to cocaine and LSD, but he discourages
alcohol? I am not saying I endorse binge drinking while
breastfeeding, I am pointing out the irony.)
Pumping and Dumping
It would be extremely rare that a mother would need to
pump and discard her milk, as most drugs pass into and
then out of milk as the mother's blood levels drop.
However, there are some occasions when complete
cessation or short-term pumping and discarding would be
advisable. This is particularly important with various
radioactive drugs, certain anticancer drugs, drugs of
abuse, (which are similar
to the antidepressants he so enthusiastically endorses!)
and various antibiotics (see Table 2).
In the last decade it has become increasingly evident
that breastfed babies are the healthiest of babies.
(I've never heard of formula
causing a baby to go into a coma. I am not endorsing
formula, I am pointing out that Hale endorses a drug for
breastfeeding moms that can seriously harm a baby, while
pretending that drug will not harm the baby and that
breast milk will magically protect the baby from the
effects of drug exposure. Just because mother's milk so
incredibly perfect in its untainted state doesn't mean
that babies are immune to drugs if they are breastfed.)
Every pediatrician knows that breastfeeding is
like an additional immunization, (There
he goes with the illogical garbledeegook again. No,
breastfeeding is not like an "additional immunization,"
vaccines are additional attempts to immunize. Breastfeeding is not
additional anything. It's feeding your baby the way that
moms have for millenia. It's passing the immunities to
the diseases that you've come in contact with, through
your own body, to your baby. Perhaps doctors should stop
and think about this fact of human biology before they
go calling breastfeeding "additional immunizations" and
then trying to stick your baby with a PhRMA needle. I think
I'll stick with the good old fashioned immunities that
God intended my baby to have, thank you very much.)
one that covers a wide array of bacteria, viruses, and
other infections. Regarding the use of medications by
breastfeeding mothers, many healthcare professionals
worry about litigation and advise patients to
totally discontinue breastfeeding while taking many
medications. This is not necessary. In some cases,
virtually any interruption of breastfeeding can lead
to permanent loss of milk supply.
(OK, here, we should be insisting not that the mother
stop breastfeeding, or start pumping and dumping, but
that the mother not use the dangerous drug. Besides,
even if the drug or the interruption causes milk
production to stop, it's simply not true that the loss
is permanent. Women can relactate. See
Dr. Jack
Newman's website - articles on
inducing lactation /
adoptive nursing. If we gave women as much pressure
or as much permission to try the natural route as Hale
gives them to try SSRIs, we wouldn't be looking at so
many interruptions of breastfeeding! Or, as Hale recommends, why not try REGLAN!!!!!!!! Oh, the PhRMA people have a pill for
everything, don't they? First they interrupt your milk
production with one drug, or cessation of breastfeeding,
then they restart it with some antipsychotic drugs or
REGLAN. Gee, how did the human race ever survive
millenia without the wonderful companies of PhRMA?)
The question that should always be asked is, "Is
this drug really necessary, or could the mother do
without it?" If the drug is not really necessary or
efficacious (as with cold or herbal remedies),
(he sure does hate those herbals -
and psychiatric drugs or just about any drug you could
think of aren't always necessary as many people use
alternative medicine for just about everything short of
surgical emergencies.) don't expose your
infant to it. In cases where the drug is important to
the mother's health, the proper choice of medication is
advised. Because so many physicians are not aware of the
transfer of drugs into human milk, it has increasingly
become the responsibility of the mother and other
healthcare practitioners to educate them. Help is
available from sources such as lactation consultants and
La Leche League leaders. (A
La Leche League member should educate her doctor?
Though it's true that LLL members can offer a lot of
information to moms about breastfeeding, let's not put
the burden of educating the doctor on the patients.
Besides, doctor's orders are not something you have
to follow. The real
question which the article supposedly sought to answer,
is "Is it safe for my baby? Not, "Is it "important" to
the mother's health?" Of course, most people do not
understand how harmful antidepressants are to your
health and mental state, so their knee jerk reaction is
- if Hale says it is safe, go ahead and use it. Are SSRIs safe for your baby? Hale says that Prozac is not.
He says Zoloft is safe- based on a
whopping 30 cases he
tested, in which he DID find Zoloft present in some
babies and not in others. All SSRIs have the same basic
strategy of attack on your brain and the same profile of
side effects. Some are worse than others. But if you
would not risk giving a "baby-sized" dose to your baby, based on
reading the drug label, then you should not use it while
nursing. If your doctor doesn't prescribe Zoloft to
newborns or infants, why is he or she prescribing it to you, a
breastfeeding mother?)
Human milk is the most wondrous immunization and
nutritious food you can give your infant. Removing
the infant from the breast for specious reasons should
be resisted with all the science we can muster.
Fortunately, we now have the data to support us in this
effort. (Let's take a look at
his specious reasons! How much "science" can
you muster up when you are very determined? As we have
seen from PhRMA in the past, a lot! Instead of
advocating for the idea that it's a battle between
giving a baby formula and treating the depression, a
responsible person would advocate for preserving the
breastfeeding relationship and not introducing toxic,
psychotropic medications into the mother's body, or the
baby's. A responsible person would say, breastfeed,
don't use drugs. And here are some TRULY safe
alternatives!)
◦◦◦top◦◦◦
NOTES S
1. T. W. Hale and K. F. Ilett, "Drug Therapy and
Breastfeeding," Contemporary Clinical Gynecology and
Obstetrics 1 (2001): 129-148.
2. P. A. Anderson, "Drug Use during Breast-feeding,"
(Review) Clinical Pharmacy 10 (1991): 594-624. .
3. T. W. Hale and K. F. Ilett, Drug Therapy and
Breastfeeding: From Theory to Clinical Practice (London:
Parthenon Publishing Group, 2001), 1-93.
4. P. N. Bennett, "Use of the Monographs on Drugs," in
Drugs and Human Lactation, 2nd ed. (Amsterdam: Elsevier,
1996), 67-74. .
5. "The Transfer of Drugs and Other Chemicals into Human
Milk," Pediatrics 108 (2001): 776-789.
6. Report of the Committee on Infectious Diseases: Red
Book 2000, 25th ed. (Elk Grove Village, IL: American
Academy of Pediatrics, 2000).
7. R. G. Devlin and P. M. Fleiss, "Captopril in Human
Blood and Breast Milk," J Clin Pharmacol 21 (1981):
110-113.
8. C. W. Redman et al., "The Excretion of Enalapril and
Enalaprilat in Human Breast Milk," Eur J Clin Pharmacol
38 (1990): 99.
9. B. Sandstrom and C. G. Regardh, "Metoprolol Excretion
into Breast Milk," Br J Clin Pharmacol 9 (1980):
518-519.
10. M. T. Smith et al., "Propranolol, Propranolol
Glucuronide, and Naphthoxylactic Acid in Breast Milk and
Plasma," Ther Drug Monit 5 (1983): 87-93.
11. M. J. Boutroy et al., "To Nurse When Receiving
Acebutolol: Is It Dangerous for the Neonate?" Eur J Clin
Pharmacol 30 (1986): 737-739.
12. M. S. Schimmel et al., "Toxic Effects Of Atenolol
Consumed during Breast Feeding," J Pediatr 114 (1989):
476-478. (Published erratum appears in J Pediatr 116,
no. 1 (1990): 158.)
13. See Note 7. .
14. See Note 8.
15. D. Sinclair and L. Murray, "Effects of Postnatal
Depression on Children's Adjustment to School. Teacher's
Reports." Br J Psychiatry 172 (1998): 58-63.
16. E. M. Zekoski et al., "The Effects of Maternal Mood
on Mother-infant Interaction," J Abnorm Child Psychol 15
(1987): 361-378.
17. A. Buist and H. Janson, "Effect of Exposure to
Dothiepin and Northiaden in Breast Milk on Child
Development," Br J Psychiatry 167 (1995): 370-373.
18. J. H. Kristensen et al., "Distribution and Excretion
of Sertraline and N-desmethylsertraline in Human Milk,"
Br J Clin Pharmacol 45 (1998): 453-457.
19. Z. N. Stowe et al., "Sertraline and
Desmethylsertraline in Human Breast Milk and Nursing
Infants," Am J Psychiatry 154 (1997): 1255-1260.
Thomas W. Hale, RPh, PhD, is an
associate professor of pediatrics at Texas Tech
University School of Medicine at Amarillo and a leading
authority in the field of lactation. He is the author of
three books on using drugs while breastfeeding,
including Medications and Mothers' Milk, the top-selling
reference on drugs and breastfeeding in the world. To
order any of his three books in this field or other
breastfeeding books go to
www.iBreastfeeding.com or call Pharmasoft
Publishing: 800-378-1317, 806-376-9900. In addition to
his books, Dr. Hale has an academic website for the
distribution of information on using drugs with
breastfeeding patients:
neonatal.ama.ttuhsc.edu/lact.
◦◦◦top◦◦◦
Table 1.1.
Partial list of medications of
concern or those contraindicated
Drug: Effect on lactation/infant
ACE inhibitors: High risk of hypotension in young
neonates but no problem for older infants
Acebutolol: Low blood pressure, low glucose levels, and
breathing difficulties (apnea)
Amphetamines: Loss of appetite,
agitation; risk does not justify use
Anticancer agents: Possible immunosuppression/toxicity
in neonate
Barbiturates: Monitor for infant sedation
Benzodiazepines (Valium drugs):
Chronic use may lead to infant sedation and/or
dependence
Bromocriptine (Parlodel): Inhibits lactation; suppresses
prolactin
Cabergoline (Dostinex): Inhibits lactation and prolactin
Cocaine: Infant intoxication
Ergotamine: Inhibits lactation and prolactin
Estrogens: Suppresses lactation; use with caution
Fluoroquinolones: Some may produce bloody diarrhea
Lithium: Monitor maternal/infant plasma levels and
thyroid function; use with great caution
Lovastatin and others: Lowers cholesterol; risk does not
justify use
Methotrexate: Possible immunosuppression; loss of white
blood cells; accumulation in gastrointestinal tract
NSAIDS: Avoid prolonged use of long half-life NSAIDS; GI
distress, diarrhea
Antipsychotics: May induce sedation,
increase risk of apnea
Radioactive Iodine-131: Accumulation in milk/breasts;
thyroid toxicity/carcinoma a
◦◦◦top◦◦◦
Table 2.
Radioactive and other medications
for which temporary pumping and discarding of milk is
recommended
Medication: Recommended Period of Interrupted
Breastfeeding
Radioactive Iodine-131: Complete cessation
Radioactive Iodine-123: 24 hrs for 10 mCi(millicurie);
12 hours for 4 mCi
Radioactive Iodine-125: Complete cessation
Tc-99m Pertechnetate: 24 hrs for 30 mCi; 12 hrs for 12
mCi
Tc-99m Sulfur Colloid: 6 hrs for 12 mCi
Tc-99m WBC: 24 hrs for 5 mCi; 12 hrs for 2 mCi
Gallium-67: 1 month for 4 mCi; 2 weeks for 1.3 mCi; 1
week for 0.2 mCi
Indium-111: 1 week for 0.5 mCi
Thallium-201: 24-48 hrs following 111 MBq (megabecquerel)
Cisplatinin: 3-7 days postinfusion
Cocaine: 24 hours
Metronidazole: 12-24 hours following 2-gram dose only
Doxorubicin: Complete cessation
Copper-64: 50 hours
◦◦◦top◦◦◦
Table 3.Some of many medications
considered safe for use by breastfeeding mothers
Penicillin antibiotics
Cephalosporin antibiotics
Flagyl (Metronidazole)
Reglan (metoclopramide)
Zoloft (sertraline)
******************Considered safe
by someone who doesn't know a lot about Zoloft and
measured a whopping 30 babies
Paxil (paroxetine)
*******************The most addictive of the SSRIs on
the market!
Motrin, Advil (Ibuprofen)
Tylenol (acetaminophen)
Inderal (propranolol)
Zithromax (azithromycin)
Erythromycin antibiotics
Codeine
Morphine at moderate doses
Pepcid(famotidine)
Prilosec (omeprazole)
Heparin
Insulin
Diflucan (fluconazole)
All vaccines
Ideal drug characteristics for
breastfeeding mothers:
Drugs with shorter half-lives
Drugs with poor oral absorption
Drugs low in toxicity
Drugs that are non-sedating
Suggestions for breastfeeding mothers
Use medications only when necessary.
Be flexible; choose medications that are preferred for
breastfeeding mothers.
Medications cleared by the FDA for infants are generally
safe for breastfeeding mothers, too.
Avoid maternal peak blood levels when breastfeeding.
Use drugs that are poorly absorbed or inactive orally.
Use drugs with shorter half-lives. |
|
|